Oatmeal Cream Pie

$4.99

Bring back nostalgic memories from your childhood with these puffy, chewy, sweet delights. Baked with brown sugar, molasses and spices, and filled with creamy icing, our gluten-free and dairy-free Oatmeal Cream Pies will melt in your mouth. Two fabulous pies per bag — pick up, come in, or have your Oatmeal Cream Pies shipped (leaving our bakery on Tuesdays and Thursdays, allowing 3–4 days of baking time so that you receive the freshest batch). To pick up, select PICK UP twice during checkout.

Full Description
Add to wishlist

Create Wishlist

Bring back nostalgic memories from your childhood with these puffy, chewy, sweet delights. Baked with brown sugar, molasses and spices, and filled with creamy icing, our gluten-free and dairy-free Oatmeal Cream Pies will melt in your mouth. Two fabulous pies per bag — pick up, come in, or have your Oatmeal Cream Pies shipped (leaving our bakery on Tuesdays and Thursdays, allowing 3–4 days of baking time so that you receive the freshest batch). To pick up, select PICK UP twice during checkout.

Current Stock:
Shipping: occurs between 3–4 days from the date of your order so that you receive the freshest batch. St. Michaels Pick Up: at selected day and time. Select PICK UP or SHIP Twice: during checkout.
Width: 3.50 (in)
Height: 3.50 (in)
Depth: 3.50 (in)

Customer Reviews Write a Review

Needs More
4 Stars

The cookie is quite delicious, but it needs more cream. It's alot of cookie and not enough filling. I did add vanilla ice cream to make an ice cream sandwich, which was good.